Fouls and misconduct: 46 solved cases
46 match situations on fouls and misconduct, solved with the IFAB Laws of the Game. Each case gives the correct decision —how play restarts and whether there is a disciplinary sanction— and the explanation from the Laws.
1. Careless tackle in midfield
Situation: A defender arrives late to a 50-50 ball and catches the attacker's leg carelessly.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a careless tackle involving physical contact is penalised with a direct free kick. A careless challenge does not require a yellow card.
2. Reckless tackle
Situation: A player goes in with considerable force and without enough regard for the danger to the opponent.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a reckless action shows disregard for the danger to, or consequences for, an opponent and must be cautioned with a yellow card.
3. Tackle with excessive force
Situation: A defender makes a tackle with excessive force, endangering the opponent's safety.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: using excessive force or endangering the safety of an opponent is serious foul play and requires a sending-off.
4. Push away from the ball
Situation: A player deliberately pushes an opponent while the ball is in play.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: pushing an opponent is an offence penalised with a direct free kick when the ball is in play.
5. Reckless push
Situation: A player recklessly pushes an opponent during a challenge.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: contact made in a reckless manner is penalised with a direct free kick and a yellow card.
6. Shirt pull
Situation: A defender clearly grabs the attacker's shirt to stop him moving forward.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: holding an opponent is a direct free kick offence.
7. Holding to stop a promising attack
Situation: A defender grabs the attacker just as a promising attack begins.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: stopping a promising attack with a direct free kick offence may require a caution for unsporting behaviour.
8. Trip outside the area
Situation: A defender tries to play the ball but trips the attacker outside the penalty area.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: tripping or attempting to trip an opponent is a direct free kick offence.
9. Trip inside the area
Situation: A defender trips an attacker inside his own penalty area.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Laws 12 and 14: a direct free kick offence committed inside the defender's own penalty area is penalised with a penalty kick.
10. Fair tackle on the ball
Situation: The defender clearly plays the ball first and the contact with the attacker afterwards is a normal result of the challenge.
- Restart Play on
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: not every challenge with contact is an offence. If the action is fair and the contact is a normal result of the challenge, play continues.
11. Serious foul play
Situation: A player lunges violently at an opponent while challenging for the ball, endangering his safety.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a tackle or challenge that endangers the safety of an opponent with excessive force is serious foul play.
12. Violent conduct off the ball
Situation: A player deliberately strikes an opponent when neither is challenging for the ball.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: using or attempting to use excessive force or brutality against an opponent when not challenging for the ball is violent conduct.
13. Dangerous play without contact
Situation: A player raises his leg dangerously close to an opponent's head, without making contact.
- Restart Indirect free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: playing in a dangerous manner without physical contact is penalised with an indirect free kick.
14. Fair charge
Situation: A player fairly charges an opponent shoulder to shoulder while both are challenging for the ball.
- Restart Play on
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a charge is fair when the ball is being challenged for, shoulder to shoulder, and it is not careless, reckless or with excessive force.
15. Impeding without contact
Situation: A player deliberately moves into an opponent's path without making physical contact.
- Restart Indirect free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: impeding the progress of an opponent without contact is penalised with an indirect free kick.
16. Tactical foul on the counter-attack
Situation: A player grabs an opponent to stop a promising counter-attack.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: stopping a promising attack with a penalised offence can be unsporting behaviour and require a caution.
17. Tackle from behind with no chance of the ball
Situation: A defender charges into a running opponent from behind with no chance of playing the ball.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a tackle from behind that does not challenge for the ball and endangers the opponent's safety is penalised with a foul and a direct red card.
18. Kicking the ball away to delay the restart
Situation: The referee awards a direct free kick to the other team and a player kicks the ball away to stop a quick restart.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: deliberately kicking the ball away to delay the restart is cautioned. Play restarts with the direct free kick already awarded.
19. Impeding with contact
Situation: A defender moves into an attacker's path and blocks him with body contact.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: impeding an opponent's progress with contact is a direct free kick offence.
20. Impeding without contact
Situation: A player deliberately moves into an opponent's path to stop him reaching the ball, without physical contact.
- Restart Indirect free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: impeding the progress of an opponent without physical contact is penalised with an indirect free kick.
21. Dangerous play with contact
Situation: A player plays in a dangerous manner and there is physical contact with the opponent.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: when playing in a dangerous manner results in physical contact, it becomes a contact offence penalised with a direct free kick.
22. Fair shoulder charge
Situation: Two players challenge for the ball and one fairly charges the other shoulder to shoulder, without holding, pushing or using excessive force.
- Restart Play on
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a fair charge while challenging for the ball is not an offence.
23. Holding to stop a counter-attack
Situation: A player grabs an opponent who is starting a promising counter-attack and stops him.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: stopping a promising attack with an offence is unsporting behaviour and must be cautioned with a yellow card.
24. Careless tackle, no card
Situation: A defender arrives late and catches the attacker carelessly, but without disregard for the danger or excessive force.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a careless action is a foul, but does not require a yellow card unless other disciplinary criteria apply.
25. Reckless tackle
Situation: A defender goes in hard and shows disregard for the danger to the opponent while challenging for the ball.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a reckless tackle must be penalised with a direct free kick and a yellow card.
26. Tackle with excessive force
Situation: A defender lunges at the opponent with excessive force and endangers his safety.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: using excessive force or endangering the safety of an opponent is serious foul play and requires a sending-off.
27. Violent conduct, no challenge for the ball
Situation: A player deliberately strikes an opponent when neither is challenging for the ball.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: using or attempting to use excessive force or brutality against an opponent when not challenging for the ball is violent conduct and requires a sending-off.
28. Spitting at an opponent
Situation: A player deliberately spits at an opponent and the spit hits him.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: spitting at an opponent is a sending-off offence.
29. Biting
Situation: During a challenge, a player deliberately bites an opponent.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: biting an opponent is violent conduct and a sending-off offence.
30. Careless tackle from behind
Situation: A defender comes in from behind, carelessly catches the attacker and brings him down, but without endangering his safety.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: coming from behind does not in itself mean a sending-off. If the action is only careless and does not reach the level of serious foul play, it is penalised as a foul.
31. Tackle from behind with excessive force
Situation: A defender lunges in from behind with excessive force and endangers the opponent's safety.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a tackle from any direction that uses excessive force or endangers the safety of an opponent is serious foul play.
32. Push inside the area
Situation: A defender pushes an attacker inside his own area while the ball is in play.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Laws 12 and 14: pushing is a direct free kick offence. If it happens inside the defender's area, a penalty kick is awarded.
33. Foul off the field as part of play
Situation: Two players briefly go off the field during a challenge, and a defender deliberately holds the attacker just beyond the touchline to stop him continuing.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: certain offences committed off the field as part of play are penalised according to where they happen. Holding is still a direct free kick offence.
34. Foul after the ball has gone out
Situation: The ball has wholly crossed the touchline and afterwards a defender moves an attacker aside with a light push, without violence.
- Restart Throw-in
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: with the ball out of play, a physical offence is not penalised with a free kick: play restarts with the throw-in already due. If the action were unsporting or violent, it would also be sanctioned disciplinarily.
35. Dangerous play near an opponent
Situation: A player attempts a bicycle kick with an opponent very close, forcing him to avoid contact, although there is no physical contact.
- Restart Indirect free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: playing in a dangerous manner without contact is penalised with an indirect free kick when it prevents the opponent from playing the ball for fear of injury.
36. Charge with excessive force
Situation: A player charges an opponent with clearly excessive intensity and endangers his safety.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a charge that uses excessive force or endangers the safety of an opponent is serious foul play.
37. Object thrown at the ball inside the area
Situation: From inside his area, a defender deliberately throws a boot and hits the ball to stop it reaching an attacker.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: throwing an object at the ball is penalised with a direct free kick. If a defender does it inside his own area, the restart is a penalty kick.
38. Player leaves the field to commit a foul
Situation: A defender briefly leaves the field and, as part of the play, holds an attacker just beyond the line to stop him.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: an offence committed off the field as part of play can be penalised. Holding is a direct free kick offence.
39. Two offences in a row
Situation: A player enters the field without permission and immediately makes a reckless tackle on an opponent.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: if a player commits two separate cautionable offences, even one straight after the other, he receives two cautions and is sent off. Play restarts with a direct free kick for the reckless tackle.
40. Holding that starts outside and continues inside
Situation: A defender starts holding an attacker outside the penalty area and keeps holding him until they are both inside the area.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: when a defender starts holding an opponent outside the area and continues inside it, the restart is a penalty kick.
41. Fair tackle with contact afterwards
Situation: A defender clearly plays the ball first with a fair tackle, and the attacker then falls from the normal contact of the challenge.
- Restart Play on
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: fair contact resulting from a correct challenge is not automatically a foul.
42. Indirect free kick for dangerous play
Situation: A player raises his boot dangerously near an opponent's head; there is no contact, but the opponent pulls out to avoid injury.
- Restart Indirect free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: dangerous play without contact is penalised with an indirect free kick.
43. Verbal exchange with no offence
Situation: Two players exchange normal words during a challenge, without insulting, threatening or provoking each other.
- Restart Play on
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: not every verbal exchange is misconduct. It becomes punishable when the language or behaviour is offensive, insulting, abusive or otherwise improper.
44. Celebration without leaving the field
Situation: A player celebrates a goal by sliding on the grass, without provocative gestures or removing his shirt.
- Restart Play on
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: normal celebrations are allowed unless they include forbidden behaviour, such as provocative gestures, climbing fences or removing the shirt.
45. Persistent offences
Situation: A player commits several minor fouls during the match and carries on after repeated warnings.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: persistent infringement of the Laws is cautioned. The current foul is also penalised according to its nature.
46. Offence against the referee
Situation: A player deliberately pushes the referee during play.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: using force or violent conduct against a match official is a sending-off offence.