Denying a goal-scoring opportunity: 20 solved cases
20 match situations on denying a goal-scoring opportunity, solved with the IFAB Laws of the Game. Each case gives the correct decision —how play restarts and whether there is a disciplinary sanction— and the explanation from the Laws.
1. Handball denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity
Situation: A defender deliberately stops with his hand a ball that was heading into an empty net.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: deliberate handball that denies a goal or an obvious goal-scoring opportunity is a sending-off offence.
2. Handball DOGSO inside the area
Situation: A defender commits a non-deliberate handball inside his area and denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: when a non-deliberate handball denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity and a penalty is awarded, the player is cautioned.
3. DOGSO while attempting to play the ball
Situation: Inside the area, a defender brings down an attacker who had an obvious goal-scoring opportunity while trying to play the ball.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: if the offence inside the area is an attempt to play the ball and denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity, it is a penalty and a yellow card.
4. DOGSO with no attempt to play the ball
Situation: A defender deliberately holds the attacker inside the area to stop an obvious goal-scoring opportunity, with no real chance of playing the ball.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity with an offence that is not an attempt to play the ball, such as holding, normally requires a sending-off.
5. Penalty conceded by the goalkeeper
Situation: The goalkeeper comes off his line, carelessly brings down the attacker inside the area and denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Laws 12 and 14: a careless challenge by the goalkeeper that denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity in the area is penalised with a penalty kick and a yellow card.
6. Deliberate handball in the area, no DOGSO
Situation: A defender deliberately handles the ball inside his own area during a normal challenge, without stopping a promising attack or an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: deliberate handball inside the defender's area is penalised with a penalty kick. No card is needed unless other disciplinary criteria apply.
7. Handball DOGSO outside the area
Situation: Outside his area, a defender commits a non-deliberate handball that clearly stops the ball reaching an attacker with an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a non-deliberate handball that denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity outside the player's own penalty area is a sending-off offence.
8. Handball DOGSO inside the area
Situation: A defender accidentally handles the ball inside his own area and thereby denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: when a non-deliberate handball denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity inside the area and a penalty is awarded, the player is cautioned.
9. DOGSO by holding outside the area
Situation: A defender deliberately holds an attacker who is clearly heading for goal and denies him an obvious goal-scoring opportunity outside the area.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity by holding an opponent is a sending-off offence when the penalty-area reduction in sanction does not apply.
10. DOGSO in the area while attempting to play the ball
Situation: A defender tries to play the ball inside his area, brings down the attacker and denies him an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: when the offence that denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity inside the area is an attempt to play the ball and a penalty is awarded, the defender is cautioned.
11. DOGSO in the area with no chance of playing the ball
Situation: A defender grabs the attacker inside the area with no chance of playing the ball and denies him an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity inside the area by holding, without attempting to play the ball, is still a sending-off offence.
12. DOGSO by the goalkeeper outside the area
Situation: After coming out of his area, the goalkeeper fouls the attacker outside it during an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: the goalkeeper is treated like any other player outside his area. A foul that denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity outside the area is a sending-off offence.
13. Foul in the area without DOGSO
Situation: A defender carelessly trips an attacker inside his area; the attacker did not have an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Laws 12 and 14: a direct free kick offence inside the defending area is penalised with a penalty kick. With no further disciplinary criteria, no card is shown.
14. Goalkeeper outside the area and DOGSO
Situation: The goalkeeper comes out of the area and brings down an attacker who had the ball under control and a clear run at goal.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: outside the area, the goalkeeper can commit a DOGSO offence like any player. If the foul denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity, a red card is shown.
15. Defender deliberately handles to stop a pass
Situation: A defender deliberately moves his arm towards a pass inside his area, but the ball was not heading towards an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: a defender's deliberate handball inside his own area is penalised with a penalty kick. No card is needed unless another disciplinary criterion is met.
16. Tactical foul by holding outside the area
Situation: A defender holds an attacker outside the penalty area to stop a promising attack, but it is not an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: holding to stop a promising attack is unsporting behaviour and requires a caution.
17. DOGSO in the area while playing the ball
Situation: A defender tries to play the ball inside his area, makes a reckless tackle and denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity. The attacker keeps the ball.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: the offence that denies the obvious goal-scoring opportunity is an attempt to play the ball inside the area. A penalty is awarded and the defender is cautioned.
18. DOGSO by holding inside the area
Situation: A defender with no real chance of playing the ball deliberately pulls the attacker's shirt inside the area and denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: holding an opponent to deny an obvious goal-scoring opportunity, without attempting to play the ball, is a sending-off offence even inside the area.
19. Holding that continues into the area with DOGSO
Situation: A defender starts holding an attacker with an obvious goal-scoring opportunity outside the area and keeps holding him inside the area until he falls.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: the holding continues inside the area and denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity without attempting to play the ball. Play restarts with a penalty kick and the defender is sent off.
20. Goalkeeper outside the area and deliberate handball
Situation: The goalkeeper leaves the penalty area and deliberately handles the ball outside it to stop an attacker with a clear run at goal.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: outside the penalty area the goalkeeper has no handling privileges. Deliberate handball that denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity is a sending-off offence.