Penalty kick: 5 solved cases
5 match situations on penalty kick, solved with the IFAB Laws of the Game. Each case gives the correct decision —how play restarts and whether there is a disciplinary sanction— and the explanation from the Laws.
1. Goalkeeper with one foot forward at a penalty
Situation: During a penalty kick, the goalkeeper has part of one foot touching or in line with the goal line when the ball is kicked.
- Restart Play on
- Sanction No card
- Law 14
Why: Law 14: when the ball is kicked, the goalkeeper must have at least part of one foot touching, in line with, or behind the goal line.
2. Goalkeeper completely off the line at a penalty
Situation: The goalkeeper leaves the goal line completely before the kick and his illegal position clearly affects the kicker.
- Restart Retake
- Sanction No card
- Law 14
Why: Law 14: when the ball is kicked, the goalkeeper must have at least part of one foot on or in line with the goal line. If he moves off it, the ball does not go in and his offence clearly affects the kicker, the penalty is retaken; for his first offence he is warned and for further offences he is cautioned.
3. Penalty taken by the wrong player
Situation: Another player was identified to take the penalty, but a teammate takes the kick instead.
- Restart Indirect free kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 14
Why: Law 14: if the penalty is taken by a player other than the one identified, an indirect free kick is awarded to the defending team. The player who took it is cautioned.
4. Penalty kicked backwards
Situation: The kicker takes the penalty and the ball clearly moves backwards.
- Restart Indirect free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 14
Why: Law 14: the ball must be kicked forward at a penalty kick. If it moves backwards, the kicker's offence is penalised with an indirect free kick.
5. Deliberate second touch at a penalty
Situation: The kicker takes the penalty and deliberately plays the ball again before any other player touches it.
- Restart Indirect free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 14
Why: Law 14: the kicker may not touch the ball a second time before another player has touched it. A deliberate second touch is penalised with an indirect free kick.