Advantage: 10 solved cases
10 match situations on advantage, solved with the IFAB Laws of the Game. Each case gives the correct decision —how play restarts and whether there is a disciplinary sanction— and the explanation from the Laws.
1. Accidental handball with no consequence
Situation: The ball accidentally hits a player's arm and he gains no relevant immediate advantage.
- Restart Play on
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: not every touch of the ball with the hand or arm is an offence. The criteria for a handball offence must be met.
2. Advantage and goal
Situation: A defender commits a foul that stops a promising attack, but the attacker carries on, enters the area and scores.
- Restart Goal
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: if advantage is played and a goal is scored as a result, no yellow card is shown for an offence that only stopped a promising attack.
3. Shirt pull with no further advantage
Situation: A defender clearly grabs an attacker's shirt during a challenge.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: holding an opponent is a direct free kick offence.
4. Advantage and goal after a tactical foul
Situation: A defender stops a promising attack with a foul, but the attacker keeps the ball and scores immediately.
- Restart Goal
- Sanction No card
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: if advantage is played and the attacking team scores as a result, the goal is awarded. No yellow card is shown for an offence whose only purpose was to stop a promising attack.
5. Advantage after DOGSO without a goal
Situation: Outside the area, a defender denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity with a foul. The referee plays advantage, but the attack ends with a shot wide.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: if advantage is played after an offence that denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity and no goal is scored, the disciplinary sanction is applied at the next stoppage. As it was outside the area, it is a sending-off.
6. Goal after a defender's accidental handball and advantage
Situation: A defender accidentally handles the ball inside the area, the ball reaches an attacker and he scores immediately.
- Restart Goal
- Sanction No card
- Law 5
Why: Laws 5 and 12: if the referee plays advantage and the attack scores as a result, the goal is awarded. The disciplinary sanction that a DOGSO would have required is not applied if the goal comes directly from the advantage.
7. Foul in the area and a second foul by the defender
Situation: A defender commits a careless foul inside the area. Before the referee can stop play, the same defender commits a reckless foul on the same attacker.
- Restart Penalty kick
- Sanction Yellow
- Law 5
Why: Laws 5 and 12: when several offences occur before the restart, the most serious one is penalised. The second, reckless tackle brings the caution, and a penalty kick is awarded for the direct free kick offence inside the area.
8. Accidental handball and advantage in the area
Situation: A defender accidentally handles the ball inside the area, but it falls straight to an attacker with an empty net, who scores.
- Restart Goal
- Sanction No card
- Law 5
Why: Laws 5 and 12: advantage can be played after a handball offence. If the attack scores as a result of the advantage, the goal is awarded.
9. Goalkeeper outside the area, foul and advantage
Situation: The goalkeeper comes out of the area and commits a careless foul on an attacker, who keeps the ball. The referee plays advantage and the attacker then scores.
- Restart Goal
- Sanction No card
- Law 5
Why: Laws 5 and 12: when advantage is played and the attack scores as a result, the goal is awarded. The disciplinary sanction for the original foul follows the advantage provisions.
10. DOGSO offence and the attacker plays on
Situation: Outside the area, a defender makes a reckless tackle that denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity. The attacker stays on his feet and shoots straight away, but the ball goes wide.
- Restart Direct free kick
- Sanction Red
- Law 12
Why: Law 12: if the referee does not play advantage, or the following play does not bring the necessary benefit, the offence that denied the obvious goal-scoring opportunity outside the area is still a sending-off.